Adjust the package in the trade calculator, or compare both assets in the2026 dynasty rankings.
Tyler Shough vs Carnell Tate
Straight-up dynasty trade value for Tyler Shough and Carnell Tate, updated Oct 14, 2026. Values byDynasty Dealer.
Fair Trade
This is a fair trade
Straight up, Tyler Shough for Carnell Tate is within 5% on value (4.1% apart) — the market calls it even. Roster fit and your contention window should decide, not the numbers.
Who the market prices higher
The market separates Tyler Shough and Carnell Tate by only 491 points (4.1% of the combined value), which is inside the 5% band TradeGauge treats as even. Neither manager is winning on value alone.
Contender or rebuilder
Carnell Tate is 6 years younger, so a rebuilding roster should lean that way even where the raw value is close — youth compounds, while a contending roster is buying the remaining peak seasons instead.
Position and scarcity
Positional scarcity matters here: 13 QBs are priced at or above 6,297 (33% of that tier), against 17 WRs at or above 5,806 (33%). The thinner side of that comparison is harder to replace if you trade it away.
Which way the market is moving
Over the last seven days of snapshots, Tyler Shough is up 645 and Carnell Tate is down 554. Momentum currently favors Tyler Shough — worth weighing if you are the side asking, since the market has not finished repricing.
What balances it
Straight up is already fair. If either manager adds a piece, the trade tips — check the package in the calculator rather than eyeballing it, because three mid assets do not add up to one elite asset.Run the full package →
Dynasty market values, updated · data version 2026-10-14 · sourceDynasty Dealer. These are estimated trade-market values, not projected fantasy points.
More on the decision: rebuild vs contend andhow trade values work.
Track Tyler Shough and Carnell Tate
Values swing all season. Get an email when either player makes a big move, so you buy low and sell high before the other manager notices.
TradeGauge Pro
Turn a market answer into your next move
Find balancing pieces for your trade, explore matches for your connected league, and keep your decisions in one place.
$9.99/month or $59.99/year
Take TradeGauge with you on iPhone
The market verdict stays free. On iPhone, save the trade, scan one Sleeper roster free, and add roster-aware targets and value alerts when you want the full edge.
- One free roster scan
- Saved trade history
- Value-move alerts
